St. Vincent Archabbey’s response to an April 2, 2013 letter makes it clear that Douglas Nowicki was, in fact, under various forms of investigation concerning allegations of misconduct from some time in 2009 until July of 2012. During that time, Douglas Nowicki was reelected Archabbot, in May of 2010.
View allegations of sexual misconduct against Nowicki… Here
View the Carr letter as a PDF… Here (File Size: 28 Mb)
View the Archabbey’s response… Here